top of page

Mother's Birthday Wish

Shortly after my divorce, in the lingering details of final separation, I unlocked the basement door of the now-for-sale house to get my last cartons. The new bittersweet freedom nudged me to reawaken my old dream of writing, and files of unfinished manuscripts rested here, waiting for resuscitation. I descended the dusty stairs with an unpleasant mix of familiarity and no longer belonging. Rummaging in the dim light, I pushed away discarded furniture and half-used paint cans.

My cartons were wedged in a corner, and my eye caught a box marked "Mom." During her final illness, my mother and I, having thrashed through the inevitable generational battles, became close. After clearing out her apartment, I kept some of her things.

I sat on the damp cement floor, hardly remembering what was in the box, and opened it. On the top, tied with gritty string, lay a packet encrusted with dust like old frosting. I brushed it off and broke the string.

In my hands separated two music scores. Their blue-gray covers had faded in spots to yellowed patches, and they emanated the musty, sweet smell of old books, victims of disuse and little air.

The scores were for a Brahms symphony and the Mendelssohn violin concerto. They were the size of small paperbacks, meant to fit easily into a briefcase or suit pocket when you went to a concert. You held them unobtrusively near the seat lights to follow the orchestra. I'd often seen my father slip a score into his jacket before he and I opened one of the scores. Inside the front flap, I recognized with a start my mother's handwriting. Attending to her affairs in her last frail years, I’d gotten very used to it. The script, written decades earlier, was exactly the same, letters thin and wobbly like a child's:

April 5

Many happy birthdays, Darling.


Darling? Were these the parents I knew? She'd never called him that in all the years of my growing up. At the time of this card, they'd been married for two years, three years before their first child was born. The bloom was still on, and the hope.

Like every new couple, they’d started out full of wedding sparkle and family's beaming smiles. The unaccustomed feelings of love, they must have felt, would surely activate the magnificent aspirations each had held close long before they'd ever met. He would be the great violinist, she the great painter. And during the first two years that prompted my mother's dust-caked birthday wish, those dreams still crackled bright as virtuoso cadenzas.

But soon the "happiness," veneer at best, couldn't conceal my mother’s frantic attempts at perfect wifehood, bearing two children, thwarting her creative needs, or my father's despair at the corrosion of his life’s potential. In single young manhood, his dream propelled him to walk miles uphill to school to save the bus money for music lessons and work nights to buy his first third-hand violin. His fierce desire thrust him further—to the miracle of acceptance at Juilliard and dared hope of the dream reaching life.

But, as with so many couples, the jolts of adulthood insinuated and took over. And here he was, freighted with wife, children, and deadening administrative job that just supported the newly congratulated four-bedroom split-level.

Even so, he tried to regain the dream, practicing the Mendelssohn furiously on Sunday mornings and losing himself in the pocket scores at two-hour concerts. But neither they nor my mother—nor certainly the annoyance of children—could salve his psychic wounds.

These surfaced in many ways. He was tall, always a little too heavy, and, as my wide child eyes beheld him, a great stone edifice. His thunder-threatening countenance permeated the household, face blackened the sky. He wielded no physical threat, but his colossal silences and bullying rages kept my brother and me frozen inside the house and out as much as we could manage. My mother took refuge in women friends, religion, Bach cantatas, and the furtive easel and palette set up in the guest room closet.

Shortly before she died, she told me that sex had gone in six months, and "Darling" soon after, despite the card. The rest was endurance. They stayed together as casualties of social etiquette, family expectations, inertia, fear, and inbred precepts of loyalty. Locked in the struggle against each other, they denied themselves, took it out on their children, and lived the façade of suburban contentment. Until one May night, a month past his fifty-third birthday, after a harsh exchange and complaint of heartburn, he collapsed at midnight on the master bathroom floor.

My mother too paid her dear prices. She discovered early, contrary to what she'd been taught, that love and martyrdom do not conquer all. Yet she stumbled through her marriage, as if more cooking, tasteful curtains, clean children, placemats from Bloomingdale's, and constant attempts at placation would assuage his great hole of despair and somehow atone for her own “selfish” need to paint.

Although she cheered the rising women's movement, it came too late to penetrate her upbringing. So she spent the entire twenty-four years of table-setting and Sunday pot roasts denying her artist’s soul, until released by the last phrase of the vow.

After he died, for the rest of her life, she avoided all possibility of another relationship, sure any other man would again stifle and drain her. Depriving herself of male companionship, maybe even love, instead she took a few painting classes, went out with women friends, listened to more Bach cantatas, and clung to her swallowed rage.

For many years, she seemed unaffected, but the rage demanded payment. It festered, spread, and weakened her beyond medical reclamation. In her last month, at seventy-nine, she finally voiced it. “I was angry at him all our married life. I never really forgave him.”

Overtaken by these memories, I sighed as I sat on the cold floor in the dank basement air. Yes, the scores evoked bitter recollections, but now, with their shocking tender birthday wish, they felt precious in my hands. I thought of the emptiness I would now face and pain of my own failed relationship. I thought of my ex-husband, his thwarted desires for success, and my parallel history of undeclared dreams and secret resentments. Could I somehow transmute the litany of wrongs done me and the still-raw anger into forgiveness of him? And recognition of my part in our debacle?

I had to. My mother's choices had ensnared her, and the only way to divest their power was to face myself. Only then might I still nurture my writer’s soul, even find a true Darling. And on today's saner terms, beyond the old sacrosanct roles of woman and wife, which, as my mother sadly proved, could be lethal. Maybe this, and not her household items and few pieces of jewelry and framed sketches, was her real legacy.

After brushing off the scores, I tucked them into my handbag and closed the carton. Maybe I'd return for the rest of my things, maybe not. I'd recovered the most important of them.

I walked back upstairs and left the house, not looking back. With moist eyes, I silently thanked my mother for her birthday wish.


Author, editor, and writing coach, Noelle Sterne, PhD, has published over 700 pieces in literary and academic venues. Her handbook addresses doctoral candidates’ nonacademic difficulties: Challenges in Writing Your Dissertation. Noelle helps readers reach their lifelong yearnings in Trust Your Life: Forgive Yourself and Go After Your Dreams. Website:

Recent Posts

See All

Eight Belles

Bottles of the finest Scotch lined the oak-paneled wood walls where Dad and I sat at the bar in a bay side restaurant looking at the television in anticipation of the 2008 134th Run for the Roses. A f

A Sewing Circle

The moving man, stout as the load on his dolly, steered a dark wood cabinet into my mother’s apartment. He scanned the small studio, boxes stacked everywhere, for someplace to unload the heavy piece.


Bone-chilling winds, throngs of rabid Green Bay Packer fans, and I rushed into Dallas on a frigid Friday night in January. The freezing cold, a stark contrast to the seventy degrees and sunshine I lef


bottom of page